The question “Did Lyle play that song at the funeral?” has captivated audiences worldwide, sparking intense discussions about one of the most bizarre moments in true crime history.

According to author Robert Rand, who wrote a Menendez brothers biography, several Milli Vanilli songs were played at José and Kitty Menendez’s funeral including ‘Girl I’m Gonna Miss You’.

This wasn’t just a dramatization—it actually happened, leaving funeral attendees visibly confused and stunned.

More Post: 20 Eastbound and Down Funeral Songs

The Song That Shocked Everyone at the Funeral

Lyle Menendez played Milli Vanilli’s “Girl I’m Gonna Miss You” at the funeral both in the Netflix show and in real life. The choice bewildered mourners who expected traditional funeral music, not a pop hit from a duo embroiled in controversy.

This track, released in 1989, became an unexpected soundtrack to one of America’s most notorious family tragedies.

What Song Did Lyle Actually Choose for the Memorial Service?

The infamous song selection wasn’t limited to just one track. “Girl I’m Gonna Miss You” and “Blame It On The Rain” both had their moment during the memorial service.

These upbeat pop songs created a jarring contrast against the somber atmosphere of a funeral, making attendees question the brothers’ emotional state and intentions.

Why Did Lyle Play That Particular Song at His Parents’ Funeral?

According to author Robert Rand, the writer of The Menendez Murders: The Shocking Untold Story of the Menendez Family and the Killings that Stunned the Nation, the brothers chose the song to memorialise their father and mother.

The selection wasn’t random—it reflected the brothers’ complex relationship with their parents and their emotional processing of the tragedy they had orchestrated.

The Milli Vanilli Connection: More Than Just Music

The duo’s streaming numbers are booming since the Netflix series depicted how the brothers bonded over the music of Milli Vanilli, who ruled the radio that summer of 1989.

This wasn’t merely background music—it represented the soundtrack of their lives during that pivotal summer when everything changed.

Real-Life Confirmation: Did This Actually Happen?

With the show already receiving accusations that the events being portrayed in the series are inaccurate, many viewers thought that this scene might have been fiction too, but no, it did actually happen in real life.

The authenticity of this moment has been verified by multiple sources, including journalists who covered the case extensively.

The Funeral Scene’s Impact on Popular Culture

Streams of “Blame It on the Rain” increased 68% in the four-day period following the Netflix series premiere.

This demonstrates how the portrayal of Lyle’s funeral song choice has reignited interest in both the case and the music that defined that era.

Why This Song Choice Matters in Understanding the Case?

The selection of Milli Vanilli tracks at the funeral provides crucial insight into the brothers’ psychological state. Their choice to play upbeat pop music at such a solemn occasion revealed their disconnection from conventional grief expressions and social norms.

This decision continues to puzzle criminologists and the public alike.

The Lasting Legacy of That Funeral Song

Speaking to Vanity Fair, creator Ryan Murphy said: “The choice of Lyle playing a Milli Vanilli song at his parents’ memorial – you really can’t make up”.

This moment has become emblematic of the case’s surreal nature, where tragedy intersected with pop culture in the most unexpected ways.

More Post: 20 Country Funeral Songs for Saying Goodbye

Conclusion

The question “Did Lyle play that song at the funeral?” has a definitive answer: yes, he absolutely did. This bizarre musical choice at José and Kitty Menendez’s funeral remains one of the most shocking details of an already extraordinary case.

The selection of Milli Vanilli’s hits during such a somber occasion continues to fascinate and disturb audiences, serving as a haunting reminder of how reality can be stranger than fiction.